Menu visibility control

Video

Events

Startup Surgery

Most Recent

Investments

InMyBag lands £300,000 from investors including onefinestay co-founder

Need to Know

What tech giants Siemens and Apple have planned for post-Brexit Britain

Investments

London-based Vantage Power closes £2.5m pre-Series A

Press Releases

Doctor Care Anywhere selected to join the Mayor of London’s International Business trade mission
Doctor Care Anywhere partners with Aetna International to make its virtual doctor service available 24 hours a day to international patients
Starling Bank unveils beta as it begins roll out to first customers

Listen Facebook, just take my damn money!

markzuckerberg_fudyma
twitterlinkedinFacebookgoogle_plustwitterlinkedinFacebookgoogle_plus

When Facebook purchased Instagram last year part of the rationale was that Facebook was lousy with mobile and the acquisition would help.

This was no frivolous thing, with mobile uptake and activity on Facebook outstripping browser-based action, and a majority of ad revenue coming from its browser-based activities Facebook could see writing on the wall.

Treading a fine line

So the question is, how are they going? Unfortunately if recent developments are anything to go by, pretty damn poorly.

The challenge of course with mobile, is finding a way to out ads in whilst trying to adhere to that basic principle of advertising – try to avoid excessively irritating your users. There’s a fine line between ensuring you get your message across (heck a company has to make money, I get that part), and driving users to the point of homicidal distraction. Facebook’s browser ads fall into the former category.

The contrast with the experience of using mobile couldn’t be bigger. Recently, Facebook has started including full page “sponsored posts” on its mobile app. Or should I say in my case, and some others I know “a single sponsored post, repeated over and over again”.

Mine is for a trading app (see below), a friend of mine is persistently haunted by gambling app whenever he uses FB mobile.

That  the same ad comes up repeatedly and exclusively, in my case since before Christmas, is intensely irritating.

Now I should repeat at this point I do not have an objection to advertising on Facebook mobile – the company is trying to build revenue, and I’m getting what I believe to be a valuable service.

My objections are these:

Firstly, don’t fill the whole screen, you wouldn’t have an automatic pop up that fills a browser’s screen, so don’t do it on mobile. I’d happy accept if the ad came further down the News Feed.

I thought you knew me?

Secondly and more importantly, Facebook knows more about me by now than pretty much any other entity, human or otherwise, it has the capability to target me as a consumer to the point where I should be clicking without a second thought.

So why does keep hitting me with the same ad that I’ve previously ignored? (repeatedly)

This is getting back to the basic part of marketing – it turns me against both the advertiser (whoever they are) and the medium (that’s Facebook).

It makes my experience less enjoyable, it turns me onto other services like Path.

If Facebook really wanted to test the efficacy of the advertising why not include a “Dislike” button… it’s certainly controversial, but both Facebook and the advertisers would start getting solid feedback on the quality of content, as opposed to the inferred response now: Click through = good; inactivity = ??

But here’s the real kicker. I use Facebook a lot, and for all my gripes I find it a very useful service. In fact I’m getting to the point where I would certainly pay money to use it… because I’ve realised it’s utility.

So if Facebook were to offer me to pay a subscription (say £5 a month to be rid of such advertising), I’d seriously consider it… very seriously.

There’s an opportunity here for Facebook. I’m not suggesting they force people to pay a subscription, but given the choice between this sort of intrusive advertising and £60 a year… at this point I’d likely take the latter. Facebook would have a novel new revenue stream, users, and perhaps since *I* am paying Facebook rather than advertisers, they might start to show me a bit more courtesy.

So, Facebook, do the right thing, just take my damn money!

James Clark blogs at Marketing for Tech

Enter your email address to receive updates straight to your inbox

* indicates required
Send me news on...
twitterlinkedinFacebookgoogle_plustwitterlinkedinFacebookgoogle_plus

  • Elmboughs

    This is a really good idea. Folds into one comment I’ve seen that newspapers should offer ‘business class’ access where all the ads go away. It probably wouldn’t work, though-too many businesses want to know they’re getting high-income eyeballs.

    They might be better off trying to upgrade targeting-I’m not sure why I’m being offered Muslim dating…

Editor's picks

InMyBag

InMyBag lands £300,000 from investors including onefinestay co-founder
posted 15 hours ago

Brexit

What tech giants Siemens and Apple have planned for post-Brexit Britain
posted 18 hours ago

161014 Vantage Power: Reading Buses, Live trial.

London-based Vantage Power closes £2.5m pre-Series A
posted 20 hours ago

Scotland

Edinburgh-based Reactec closes £700,000 round led by Archangels
posted 22 hours ago

Edinburgh

Edinburgh’s tech accelerator Seed Haus launches £300,000 investment fund
posted on March 28, 2017

Bristol - South West of England

Top tech hubs in the South West of England
posted on March 27, 2017